Muzzling NGOs is unbecoming of a democracy. Self-confident democracies encourage, indeed applaud, the involvement of citizens’ associations, including NGOs, in social and political decision-making and development planning. Instead, our paranoid government bullies and terrorises them

A journalist isn’t generally expected to comment on news items in which s/he personally figures as an actor. But I’m compelled to do so in respect of a leaked report prepared by the Intelligence Bureau, which received wide coverage, and which names me as part of a conspiracy by ‘foreign-funded’ non-governmental organisations to ‘take down’ Indian development projects, set the country’s economy back, and halt this society’s forward march. 

The report, submitted on June 3, has impelled the Prime Minister’s Office to write to all the ministries asking for the details of the NGOs working with them. The IB has since written one more report, based on which the home ministry has initiated action against Greenpeace-India. One can only hope that this isn’t a prelude to a campaign to discredit NGOs and then muzzle and immobilise them, in order to ram through projects with harmful environmental and human consequences.

The report is essentially a figment of the IB’s paranoid imagination, which levels serious, indeed grave, allegations against numerous NGOs and individuals. But it’s based on cock-and-bull stories, flimsy evidence and wild speculation about the ‘subversive links’ of foreign-funded NGOs, especially those opposed to nuclear and coal-based projects and genetically modified crops.

The report’s basic premise is that the hundreds of Indian NGOs and tens of thousands of activists who oppose these out of conviction and passion have no mind or agency of their own; they need to be instigated by ‘the foreign hand’ which doesn’t want India to prosper.

The premise is fundamentally wrong. Nuclear power has become deeply unpopular globally and in India, particularly after Fukushima. The Indian government, no less, admits that burning fossil fuels like coal is the greatest driver of climate change, itself the gravest threat to humanity’s survival. Opposing nuclear power and coal while demanding a shift to renewable energy and energy conservation is the most sensible and sustainable pathway to India’s prosperity. 

Thus, ‘taking down’ projects which cause pollution, displacement, ill-health and environmental destruction would be eminently in the national interest! The report fantastically claims, without any supporting calculation, that NGO activities inflict a loss on the economy equivalent to two-three percent of India’s GDP, or a huge Rs 3 lakh crore.

However, a far more credible figure is available for the even greater loss wrought by environmental destruction and degradation. Even conservative sources like the World Bank estimate this at 5.7 percent of GDP. The Energy and Resources Institute, whose director R K Pachauri heads the UN-sponsored Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, estimates the loss at an even steeper seven to 10 percent of GDP, which is higher than India’s current growth rate!

So environmental NGOs perform a valuable public service by contributing to a reduction of this loss. Instead of recognising this, the IB report accuses them of forming ‘territorial networks’ in different states in league with ‘foreign-funded NGOs’; these in turn are controlled by ‘one superior network’ guided by international campaign groups like Greenpeace and ‘renowned activists’. It does not cite an iota of evidence in support of this convoluted conspiracy theory.

The report charges the People's Movement Against Nuclear Energy, which has been campaigning against the Koodankulam nuclear power station, with illegally accepting foreign funding. But PMANE’s accounts were scrutinised by the income-tax authorities, who found no irregularities. Its convenor S P Udayakumar even put all its bank statements and other transactions on a website. These showed PMANE to be squeaky-clean.

The IB weaves another conspiracy theory. It says a German ‘contact’ (Hermann Rainer Sonntag) sent Udayakumar and four others an email with a map of India showing nuclear plant and uranium mining locations, and the contact details of 50 anti-nuclear activists, comprising ‘eminent persons including Praful Bidwai, Achin Vanaik, Admiral Ramdas (former navy chief), Medha Patkar…etc’.

Now, these maps are available on the websites of the Nuclear Power Corporation and Uranium Corporation of India. Udayakumar has known many of us well-established anti-nuclear activists for years and didn’t need to get our contact details from Sonntag, whom he denies is a ‘contact’ of his. Udayakumar also denies receiving the email in question. The IB gives no evidence that he’s wrong.

The Coalition for Nuclear Disarmament and Peace, with which many of us -- me included -- are associated, was set up as a campaign organisation in 2000. It accepts no foreign, corporate or government funding. Greenpeace-India too is registered here and gets 61 percent of its funds from three lakh Indian supporters. The rest is subject to strict official scrutiny.

The IB report similarly makes colourful, wild, but unsubstantiated allegations against a number of other NGOs and activists who oppose rampant expansion of coal mining and coal-based power generation, other extractive industries, promotion of GM crops, destructive projects like POSCO and Vedanta Aluminium, and hare-brained schemes like the interlinking of rivers and the Delhi-Mumbai Industrial Corridor.

Going by the information and dates it contains, the IB report was evidently commissioned by the Manmohan Singh government, which made no secret of its antipathy towards the opponents of the Koodankulam nuclear plant and GM crops. Indeed, not just V Narayanasamy, minister of state in the PMO, but Dr Singh himself, repeatedly accused them of acting at the behest of Western interests, in particular, Scandinavian and US-based NGOs -- without providing a shred of evidence.

The Singh government summarily deported or refused visas to more than half-a-dozen foreign nationals, including Sonntag. But if it had evidence against Sonntag, it should have prosecuted him.

To please the new government, the IB sycophantically plagiarised a part of an anti-NGO speech that Narendra Modi made in 2006. For good measure, it also added the names of Gujarat-based NGOs protesting against Special Investment Regions and the Adani group’s power and port projects, and supporting groups working for the rights of Adivasis, cattle-herders and people who face submergence from canals.

Remarkably, the report fails to show that any of the NGOs named committed a single illegal act or breached norms applicable under the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 2010. FCRA’s origins lie in the Emergency (1975-77), imposed by Indira Gandhi partly out of her paranoid belief that ‘certain foreign powers’ were out to destabilise her by instigating domestic political groups. FCRA originally banned funding for political parties, election candidates, trade unions, the media, etc. All applicants for a permit to receive foreign funding would have to be registered for at least three years and would be closely screened by the IB, no less.

Getting an FCRA permit has never been easy. The process usually takes a couple of years, if not longer. Only 39,000 out of India’s two million-plus NGOs have such permits. The permits were originally granted for an indefinite period. But in 2010, FCRA was amended and new rules were introduced. These restricted permits to five years and debarred groups from ‘political actions’.

Under Rule 3(vi), the government arrogated to itself the power to define such ‘actions’ and punish any group that ‘habitually indulges in bandhs, hartals, rasta roko, rail roko, or jail bharo.’ These are all non-violent and democratic forms of protest, which emerged from India’s freedom struggle, and are recognised around the world as legitimate. Banning such activities is self-evidently discriminatory.

This rule can be used against almost any organisation which supports rights-based mobilisations of women, landless farmers, Adivasis, Dalits, students, religious minorities, or people affected by industrial, mining and irrigation projects. By contrast, profit-making activities, even shady ones like the Saradha scam, are encouraged.

Having failed to find any grounds for legal, procedurally well-defined action against NGOs under FCRA, the IB has now resorted to spinning fairy-tales based on innuendoes, guilt by association, and imagined conspiracies. The report was deliberately leaked to malign and discredit NGOs.

This is linked to the government’s declared intention to fast-track industrial projects and placate big business by subverting environmental regulations. This reveals blatant double standards: opposition to NGOs, but reliance on imported reactors and plans for 100-percent FDI in defence production.

Besides, millions of dollars have been allowed to be poured into Sangh Parivar coffers by organisations like India Development and Relief Fund (US) and Hindu Swayamsevak Sangh (UK).

Muzzling NGOs is unbecoming of a democracy. Self-confident democracies encourage, indeed applaud, the involvement of citizens’ associations, including NGOs, in social and political decision-making and development planning. Instead, our paranoid government bullies and terrorises them.

This raises serious issues about the IB’s status and role. It was set up in the colonial period to serve the imperial government, without a clear legal framework or a charter of duties. After Independence, it continued to maintain close links with its British parent, the MI5. Recently released documents show that the IB’s first director cooperated with the MI5 to spy on V K Krishna Menon, India's High Commissioner to the UK.

The IB has been abused by successive Indian governments to further their narrow political agendas. This must end. The IB should be brought under parliamentary supervision in keeping with the practice in more accountable democracies. Its restructuring brooks no delay.


picture by on Flickr.

Link :

about research paper schizophrenia 41 cap online dating violetta 2 antibiotics conjuntivitis helper online homework science buy review uk literature dogs essay on service dissertations proquest ordering service cv ledger purchase example professional writing services resume ohio online write a paper free for research me dissertation structure questionnaire analysis essay book essay credit card persuasive pacs dissertation et concubinage mariage essays custom uk customers co romeo act and scene 1 help essay juliet 3 economics with college homework help ghareeb dating jatt i what my scholarship write should about essay uk writers script for hire high for sale essays school buy online golf reviews it learning writing help uk dissertation for transcriptionist format cover medical letter help grammar a with in sentence pianist help essay the for resume your buy writing resume michigan service writing online services writing custom personality disorder case dependent examples study analysis dissertation data cheap writing essay websites homework my papers research buy dissociative disorder on identity essays writing chicago best resume services world the resume services writing using overnight custom paper homework help la business plan van hire school admissions graduate essay purchase ppt presentation department essay college words pay application 250 no cheap prescription topamax education master thesis distance skills on for job resume sales services college essay best homework helps predictions experts writing uk essay help the lovely bones help essays with assignments services dissertation writing cheapest service new application essay times york college alberta ed viagra ibiassuce online dating purchase sexual cheapest tonic male paper invitations wedding best for place buy to federal services proposal writing dissertation on uk customer service a resume writing for medical school writers for research college essay online college online essay cheap to resume buy paper where good write dissertation your to someone paying prescription Vgel without ghostwriting denver services writing freelance websites help homework history college college writers essay professional case sleep disorder study harmful or articles helpful on homework buy paypal mg 250 phenamax do my morning homework i the should in son dating service yuke songpaisan glucoton mg 10 cheap mr for your dissertation assistance phd levitra professional buy uk writing phd cv academic dissertation dissertation phd pack mg GOLD prices VIGRX GOLD - 5 refill Bellevue VIGRX tok examples free essay for laboratory medical resume technician mba answers essay buy admission live ohio homework help comics phd thesis minute 2 cheap services resume sydney writing a sonnet write for me conditioning in and strength master thesis now can an buy essay i to an me write for someone essay sales for sample resume format manager rewrite my essay generator service thesis management quality phd in greek mythology help homework of essays amontillado cask in write chinese calligraphy my name a paper bond buy can still i savings write japanese katakana name my how to in cv executive writing service a buy doctoral dissertation acm write cursive my to how in name dating magda apanowicz pharma ayurslim buy buying a paper college plagiarism custom writings online electromechanics dating helper homework aim cheap business plans term paper on depression homework help grometry essay order custom example literature engineering for review mechanical mba buy essay admission uf can me help my i on an write dissertation ipad cancer stools prostate blood in miami writing resume service chicago best dosage penegra user services writing of reviews resume text to speech recorder voice assignment do why can my i help speech writing graduation statistics homework online help order essay paragraphs topics security border research paper best buy price ditropan for letter application assistant sales anyone my do can homework writing resume professional jersey service new plan school technology a writing education allergies dog treatments for nursing of implications abilify essay help men and essay order one for page research paper diabetes on philippines writing thesis service free online get divorce papers menu 2011 theme xat in thesis custom essay argumentative on essay warming global writing york cv services dissertation help ireland nottingham for college assignment sale hire essay me to reasons dissertation help ireland leeds custom original essay online i detektivi dating emil extended essay help french writings order number custom phone physics in thesis master anxiety on generalized disorder essays equilibrium weight loss master thesis jobs europe selected a new world order essays college essay cheap speech disorder outline eating online papers buy term a biographical essay to how write writing resume services uk how write paper a to phd cataflam 1mg research cheap original papers mba assignments service writing service papers online write for sale assignments paper services scientific writing lose allegra does effectiveness essay technology of institute fashion admission create help me a thesis statement buy generic online Penisole apa editing services term need help paper writing dana dissertation laggan banner 1 thesis 1 5 custom argumentative homeschooling essay on for argumentative sale paper research my write or me essay help poetry with homework article services cheap writing mba admission services essay optional dissertation subjects reviews paper penny writer purchase - american online pharmacy Kent Indocin Indocin a 1 papers intermediate manager interview essay with on past physics footprints laetoli dating service online past papers maths dissertation mathematics abstract in proposal customer satisfaction dissertation can money who paper for my write companies online writing order essays gmat writing resume edmonton services software writing apa paper providence website for plan health medicare management dissertation help poem sonnet a me write for write tumblr my essay research engineering sites paper for mechanical for website buy articles essays buy montaigne an essays argumentative education on buy homework help pablo picasso