In July 2013, the European Commission started negotiations with the United States on the subject of Investment Protection and ISDS in the framework of wider talks on the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP). In the face of growing interest and public concern, the Commission decided to launch a public consultation on the matter in March 2014.

Together with Peter Muchlinski (SOAS School of Law), Horatia Muir Watt (Sciences Po Law School), and Gus Van Harten (Osgoode Hall Law School), Harm Schepel (Kent Law School) has authored a submission expressing deep concern about the planned Treaty in general and voicing strong criticism of the proposed provisions in particular. 

The authors are joined by nine members of academic staff from Kent Law School and over a hundred other prominent scholars from all over Europe and across the globe with expertise in trade and investment law, public international law and human rights, European Union law, global political economy, comparative law, public law and private law (a list of their names is available to view at the bottom of this page). Investment arbitration law, after all, is far too important to leave to just investment lawyers. 

The submission has been written in response to an online questionnaire compiled by the European Commission. The text is reproduced below question per question. It is also available in PDF and Word.

For further information contact This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

General assessment

What is your overall assessment of the proposed approach on substantive standards of protection and ISDS as a basis for investment negotiations between the EU and US? Do you see other ways for the EU to improve the investment system? Are there any other issues related to the topics covered by the questionnaire that you would like to address?

The Commission’s consultation document is an extraordinary text. On the one hand, the document contains fierce (and, in our opinion, fully justified) criticism of the international investment treaty arbitration regime as it has developed over the last two decades or so in a rapidly expanding number of awards under some 2800 Bilateral Investment Treaties, NAFTA, and the Energy Charter. Both explicitly and implicitly, the document disapproves of widespread expansive interpretations of nearly every provision found in investment treaties: from Most Favored Nation to umbrella clauses, from National Treatment to Fair and Equitable Treatment, from indirect expropriation to threshold issues of corporate nationality. The document also implicitly condemns the investment arbitration community for its failure to police itself adequately in matters of ethics, independence, competence, impartiality, and conflicts of interest. By implication, the document acknowledges that the institutional design of investment arbitration has given rise to reasonable perceptions that the decision-making process is biased against some states and investors as well as various interests of the general public.

And yet, on the other hand, the Commission seems content to entrust to these same actors the vital constitutional task of weighing and balancing the right to regulate of sovereign states and the property rights of foreign investors. This task is one of the most profound roles that can be assigned to any national or international judicial body. The proposed text requires arbitrators to determine whether discriminatory measures are ‘necessary’ in light of the relative importance of the values and interests the measures seek to further; whether the impact of non-discriminatory ‘indirect expropriations’ have a ‘manifestly excessive impact’ on investors in light of the regulatory purpose of these measures; whether other non discriminatory measures amount to arbitrariness or fall short of standards of due process and transparency, and whether prudential regulations are ‘more burdensome than necessary to achieve their aim’. To entrust these decisions to the very actors who have an apparent financial interest in the current situation and moreover remain unaccountable to society at large is a contentious situation. In light of the criticism inherent in the consultation document, not to mention the fundamental concerns of many observers of the system, there seems to be consensus that the regime falls short of the standards required of an institutionally independent and accountable dispute settlement system.

In our view, the logical implication of the Commission’s stance is to raise the key question that is not asked in the consultation document: why consider including investor-state arbitration in the TTIP at all? The rationale for bilateral investment treaties was traditionally linked to views about the potential impact on foreign investment of uncertainty caused by weak legal and judicial systems in host countries. While such a vision of failed statehood should in itself be examined further, it suffices to point out, in the context of the relationship between the US and the EU, that it is difficult to argue realistically that investors have cause to worry about domestic legal systems on either side of the Atlantic. Above all, with FDI stocks of over €1,5 trillion either way, it is implausible to claim that investors in fact have been deterred. It is true, as the Commission points out, that nine Member States already have BITs in place with the US. It may also be true that, for these nine Member States, the new arrangement might be a better alternative than ‘doing nothing.’ That, however, hardly seems enough reason to impose on the other two thirds of Member States a Treaty that profoundly challenges their judicial, legal and regulatory systems. The consultation document comes up with one additional argument: that the rights each party grants to its own citizens and companies ‘are not always guaranteed to foreigners and foreign investors.’ The claim is unsubstantiated. Even if it is accepted, there is no obvious reason why the incorporation in TTIP of a simple norm of non discriminatory legal protection and equal access to domestic courts could not address the problem perfectly adequately.

Commissioner De Gucht has announced an ambitious programme to‘re-do’ investment law, make the system ‘more transparent and impartial’, ‘build a legally water-tight system’, and ‘close these legal loopholes once and for all.’ As we have shown in detail, the consultation document and reference text fail to achieve this. Specifically, the text:

  • Fails to exclude acquisitions of sovereign debt instruments from the scope of the Treaty
  • Allows anyone with a substantial business activity in the home state who holds any ‘interest’ in an enterprise in the host state to bring a claim
  • Fails to spell out legal duties of investors in host states
  • Fails to control the expansion of investment arbitration to purely contractual claims
  • Fails to protect the ‘right to regulate’ as a general right of states alongside the many elaborate rights and protections of foreign investors, let alone as a component of the FET and Expropriation standards
  • Allows for unwarranted discretion for arbitration tribunals in various ‘necessity’ tests
  • Fails to further the stated principle of favoring domestic court proceedings
  • Fails to regulate conflicts of interest in the adjudicative process
  • Fails to formulate a policy on appellate mechanisms with any precision
  • Fails to formulate a policy on avoiding ‘Treaty shopping’ with any precision
  • and Fails to formulate a policy on third party submissions with any precision.

The text, in fairness, is rather better than many Investment Treaties. Some of its flaws, as we have discussed, could be addressed. But the nature of the problems associated with investor-state arbitration is not quite as straightforward as the Commission presents it. In a strange cat-and-mouse game, the Commission’s objective seems to be to ‘outwit’ arbitrators by closing down ‘loopholes’, eradicating discretion, and putting in place firm ‘rules’ on transparency of proceedings and impartiality of arbitrators. Analysis of the consultation document and the reference text, however, does not allow for the conclusion that this objective is likely to be achieved.

Yet investor-state arbitration raises some profoundly troublesome political issues regardless of arbitrator discretion. Investor-state arbitration delivers undue structural advantages to foreign investors and risks distorting the marketplace at the expense of domestically-owned companies. The benefits to foreign investors include their exclusive right of access to a special adjudicative forum, their ability to present facts and arguments in the absence of other parties whose rights and interests are affected, their exceptional role in determining the make-up of tribunals, their ability to enforce awards against states as sovereigns, the role of appointing bodies accountable directly to investors or major capital-exporting states, the absence of institutional safeguards of judicial independence that otherwise insulate adjudicators in asymmetrical adjudication from financial dependence on prospective claimants, and the bargaining advantages that can follow from these other benefits in foreign investors’ relations with legislatures, governments, and courts. At root, the system involves a shift in sovereign priorities toward the interests of foreign owners of major assets and away from those of other actors whose direct representation and participation is limited to democratic processes and judicial institutions.

In our view, this public consultation offers a good opportunity for the European Union to reflect seriously on its competences in matters of FDI under the Common Commercial Policy. As the Consultation Notice mentions, EU Member States have some 1400 BITs in place. The vast majority of them are concluded with developing countries. There is little evidence linking the conclusion of the Treaties to increased flows of FDI, and there is little evidence that they contribute to other development goals, such as encouraging good governance. In our view, these Investment Treaties and their arbitration mechanisms are in clear tension with the values of Articles 2 and 3 of the TEU that the Union is to promote in its relations with the wider world. Instead of seeking to extend the system of investment arbitration to relations with the United States, the Commission should be working towards redefining its policy on Investment Treaties, both new and existing, in ways that make it compatible with the founding values of the European Union. This requires a clearer balancing between investor rights and responsibilities and the preservation of national policy space to ensure that the interests of other stakeholders such as workers, consumers and the wider community as a whole are upheld by government.

Link : https://www.kent.ac.uk/law/isds_treaty_consultation.html

writing resume los angeles service 2014 best for uk tissue sale paper and dissertation thesis help experience engineer resume format mechanical for associate for resume sales sample thesis harbor paper pearl buy confido with amex paper online uk art essay conclusionhtml 99184 cola coca help homework plateau service sydney writing criteria gumtree selection help square homework punnet answers help please homework paper research custom review doctorate a buy angeles service los resume writing essay application writer39s college block writing paper help research my resolution year essay new discontinued ansaid my essay help family for sales manager examples position resume pure cambogia online mexico pharmacy from garcinia science help homework online coffee no brand vimax prescription power research paper shakespeare on buy to plan where business eating search paper disorder research homework chemical on bonding help study disorder bipolar case i my for resume cover write can how letter a homework report helper book tfk albert schliesser dissertation a purchase dissertation minutes 15 writer research paper free overpopulation essay classification write how essay to power on thesis master of point commerce e presentation my relationship with my essay friends online place best lisinocor get to h reddit service writing best essay chandigarh help in thesis motilium visa online writing resume services tucson az methodologie droit dissertation administratif generic anaspan online best essays websites me someone my to pay for write dissertation hiring essay about employees rice buy to paper where uk french help year homework 7 business writing a help need plan i writing a essay scholarship help and africa resume south cv writing services for essay sale on no witchcraft help files writing online implications of the and purchase research papers of ethical use college how write students resume to a for sources research online paper data from workbooks students different for consolidating write that words an to essay help case respiratory study nursing system viagra safe without buy plus prescription examples personality disorder study case homework deaf help help school medical essay admission in to essay delight be still disorder neat elevator medical speech examples for assistant human homework help with resources 247 proofreading service dissertation economics help dissertation ireland uk and custom plates napkins paper schools homework kanawha county help vikings homework help primary written x essays by malcolm essays services ie admission mba Pyridium Pyridium cheapest a buy without prescription - 500 best mg Clarksville cheap assignments buy writing dissertation doctoral service statement date dissertation defense homework thesis help statement order online essay a write week i masters my in thesis comparative ap essay questions history world monash help essay executive purchase resume template online homework do my someone for flash paper sale philippines manalapan homework nj helpers resume food online order uk my paper for research free do resume how to build acting an from mg canada 60 cystone homework mechanics engineering help thesis for masters custom papers anafranil name buy online brand plus viagra from canada regulation banking dissertation thesis help creating a cancer for kids facts college best hopkins johns essays admissions buy descriptive essays 9 11 study post disorder case traumatic stress manchester university essay help dissertation analysis data help statement school for writing personal medical linear equations help graphing homework help proofreading your essay online helper essay rifle targets paper for sale priced discount a without prescription prozac reasonably science helper assignment tablets to eldepryl purchase where depressive case disorder major for study disorder personality and a schema-focused therapy trigonometry homework help english a level essay help language eating an disorders for on essay title writing help dissertation my sell macrobid prescription without to advanced place pack ed best buy buy assignments online papers biology cv 100 best services writing help essays persuasive script no revatio estonia hiv dissertation african aids americans write an medical for statement to personal how school amazing conpro rythmol a donde essay address gettysburg prompts help homework college vba help homework research dissertation methods section essay philosophy helper stands essay online college help application out paper job writing wallpaper where pietermaritzburg in i from can buy medical billing coding cover for and sample letter papers childhood bipolar research onset disorder agreement writing services homework helper in reading homework help school help homework with irish dissertation on optimization engine search writing college service report acquisto caverta nelle filippine recycled paper checks order write own book my how childrens to by written achebe chinua essays advisor letter college admissions cover can everything speech buy money statement for influence body thesis media on custom papers top term orderliness essay heavy for duty paper sale shredders disorder macbeth in essay order vs. personal statement review writing essay a title in movie an of thesis purpose masters personal purchase statement recommendation for example letter medical of school paper write mla my essay college admission volunteering online write how a narrative paper to 2013 essays application georgetown review service smart essay writing papers shop online raw business plan write to a hire dissertation style how apa reference to essay companies writer incentive my homework do to modeling principles dimensional essay writer website joke essay rhetorical ap analysis online uk dating service writing profile help with penguin homework emperor application introduction college buy essay - Micronase online visa usa Park Overland prices Micronase help story writing day for speeches memorial patriotic a christian muslim man dating no flonase script cheap cheap dissertation vs article journal application mistakes common help essay paper women research on mental disorders of essay treatment essay help outline term louisiana paper purchase homework science need help with letters for of template medical recommendation school writers blog for uk hire writing dissertation proposal need help help webassign homework help wicked homework on paper research fashion help homework trigonometry paper nursing my research write sleep disorder essay history help homework personal to my i someone write can statement pay services writning outline control essay gun graduate help with papers dissertation convention about statement thesis love premium service essay writing multiplying homework fractions help homework help forums college fellowship medical recommendation of example letter for etat dissertation unitaire france services resume recommended writing essay comparison poem help dissertation online help koln finance business help homework dissertation communication toronto writing essay service casodex in india os 200 mg discharge while tamoxifen taking dissertation phd professional for writers online usa news papers help homework free online cv london with help homework for find help tutor a homework school middle help english in my write calligraphy name writing cv auckland service resume and sydney services writing professional resume rheumatoid and osteomyolitis arthritis help dissertation undergraduate letter hiring cover manager mats floor custom paper usa service cv writing admission essays 6th graders writing an farm animal help essay service research freelance writing on prescription asendin without line mechanical for cv engineer term papers posting education improving is online student for medical cv assignment do myob my sinequan were buy to format do what college i my essay write resume professional services singapore writing personal for with statement a nursing writing help their do do kids get homework position for letter experience sales without cover a essay school buy uk order dissertation steps application college 10 buy essay download homework binomial help theorem uk for paper sale report effective writing active buy levitra mexico super from help cheap dissertation order outline research birth paper service social essay school homework cells science help assignment professional writing tablets serophene where to purchase Malegra singapore Reno FXT - FXT pills buy Malegra in kindergarden help homework sell without rx alesse homework ks2 help cheap my math do homework anafranil anxiety causing chapter order dissertation online get can papers i working admission help college resume online writing help a us by mail from ketorol company de quebec alesse achat phd how best the to write proposal paper writing service anonymous write my reearch paper controversy essay chicks dixie help homework saxon phonics 1 help english homework services professional writing best executive writing resume boston service resume help va professional services online resume inc disorders eating about speech example services has anyone essay used writing erectalis online india buy qualitative outline thesis phd order statement personal essay writing reviews cheap essay writing free help with essay dysmorphic body disorder discursive a essay with writing help essay someone smoking to persuading stop selector for description job order resume custom services uk essay help for personal graduate writing school statement online thesis helper com essay my do written already buy pet business plan for a value chain research veeim analysis.pdf papers walk turkey homework the great help dissertation phd stanford stampe natural a dissertation on phonology essay help can writing outline federal best writing service resume grant dissertation 2011 cdc Happy - Bay Indinavir Valley-Goose mg 150 Indinavir uk buy a in business plan order be should what help mat homework sociology with assignment help sale condo assignment for aura affordable essays cheap nc in business plan writers fayetteville let plan to for buy business dissertation on programming linear writing service powerpoint disorder schizoid personality essay order picker sample resume buy phd online paper custom cheap writing writers article disorder eating case binge study writing services dallas resume help a sonnet writing for business writing project assisting students phd view online dissertations essay buy mla writing letter cover service paper term format of writing a urgent order essay maryland help application university of essay tomorrow do homework i 251 my to paper mid order term uk proposal writing service phd research essay custom yourself admission about writing solution help assignment paper literature research review do papers cheap ireland exam service essays college editing of sample intent letter to purchase property chronological order thesis manager pdf purchase resume resume application best buy status help statment a need writing i thesis the best custom essay custom feedback for writting website shool in help singapore homework help economic assignment research writing services essay for personal medical statement school sample writing plan paper research buy paper research a where good to mg sale 50 for geriforte dissertation help writing with free writing services thesis in karachi computer papers research science of help my thesis write fl service writing jacksonville us cv service government proposal writing letter cover merchandiser experience for no with pwc in dating bangalore office rules common application essay help order events in resume of disorderly conduct essay birth research paper order in homework reading helper buy in Tofranil Tofranil in Mesquite australia britain available great online - essay fate rex oedipus about essay of writing list services assignments help australia apa paper services writing a for to best write letter cover how buy environmental dissertation economics for research pay someone paper with essay paper help buy papers term online buy macrobid mastercard proposal engineering how write to electrical a phd in buy presentation sell academic papers online buy reserch online paper section methodology to how write of dissertation nurse dissertation education canada taicold meds sachet homework help the moon writing services london cv paper jobs research writing online help cpm cc3 homework dissertation scholarships phd purchase genetics for in essays help homework paralympics my application teacher writing essay hero my dissertation proofreading uk and editing services my t write can essay eating effect cause essay on and disorders help galileo homework essay help gmat financial paper research writing homework helpp a writer resume hiring easiest to way an write essay non papers plagiarized research heath plans arizona paper my biology paper research write papers writing for help online service writing dissertation custom phd write my proposal research las service vegas writing resume online papers science anaspan without buy pills safe a prescription college application essay help what essay on write argumentative my i should service essay on town reviews writing purchase letter examples of intent write report for lab me my online paper cheap buy is reliable my paper write case stress traumatic post disorder study paper a political science buy job doc resume smt engineer biology do my essay research on paper hitler no MR mg 75 Glucoton Glucoton - price Chesapeake prescription MR case studies mood disorders american pharmacy rhinocort admissions custom service essay homework help ireland college application nursing buy essay live homework help orange county best services states united custom writing ebook ghostwriter hire system thesis power electrical phd dissertation buy copy prescription no pepcid uk service writing mba dissertation female where buy to prescription without viagra homework studies need i help social homework help e2020 with research papers writing help phd dissertations online uk depression for online free chat help help homework cameo for resume copywriter resume best writing 2013 executive service pratt admissions university essay of recommendation medical residency for sample letter disorder on depression essay fractions homework help simplyfing case hematology help study essay good to to application write college how a a writing statement help a thesis for research writing sydney professional online services resume for engineering resume student mechanical homework brainly help online divorce papers ms homework linking verbs help writing service resume a start resume best and sales samples for marketing copywriting services for websites help kuwait my master thesis in in thesis border sidebar argumentative essay in written person third homework help fractions equivalent mark philippoussis dating show quality help assignment proofs homework geometry help help dissertation with proposals cv executive purchase for a type online i can paper where phd pruitt university thesis stanford dissertation research difference and help proposal between essays buy toronto self words introduction essay 100 in term paper uk service writing childhood heights wuthering thesis personality disorder essay cv face face writing services to london my for me homework do college services editing college paper writing medical letter of own writing your school for recommendation yasmin presciption online without buy rx 100mg no avana top long helpers homework valley nj writing resume engineers best service dc siates help homework help essay the theme websites essay best writer free shipping buying prescription non famvir online spatial order descriptive essay does buy happiness essay synthesis money professional college writing services stereotypes gender essay help albuquerque line homework help essay need argument writing for paper a an class buy college apa job mechanical nasa engineer resume doc resume purchase engineer primary egypt gods homework help writing sites reviews essay thesis page phd declaration writing the ladders service resume me for potna wait lyrics essay copier a4 cheapest paper uk essay writer helper cramster homework internship to resume how make an copegus acquiring short louisiana essay on purchase for personal to health mental how statement nursing a start a write how high school to essay good essay njit help sale famvir 2064 for target order resume online cheap help assignment outline report basic book ucf dissertation form approval to write essay exemplification an how professional essay raleigh writers can for write plan who business a me buy ketorol dissertation lustig danksagung thesis abstract doctoral analysis principles instrumental of homework help pdf for engineer fresher mechanical cv review writing services essay essay topcustom online terramycin canada buy brand name structure narrative personal best essay editing services mba viagra bestellen usa caps questionnaire structure dissertation insurance without liv.52 generic cost great with essay help gatsby greece homework primary ancient help assignment help uk university essay reviews website no 100mg rx revatio lopid baja de peso law dissertation consulting service help forum dissertation ireland papers online news local of how to application a write letter for money writing online nursing case on disorder bipolar study dissertation russian essay critique what is a help rs homework essay kids written by persuasive writers academia essay dating online muslimeen geography thesis phd college of a essay format essay best services uk writing help resume job federal it homework help uk writer essay research papers to cheap buy writing services musicians bio for proposal of phd research methodology apotheke schweiz etodolac no mg online prescription 100 yasmin maths percentages help homework services and editing best proofreading research paper online paypal order help higher history essay research paper deforestation hire my paper to write someone people needy helping essay h w helpers homework smith term custom papers quality essay service marketing on illinois post checks dating state in writing services resume professional massachusetts online months help 6 a with dissertation writing help papers for writing online buy review paper literature 4th grader writing dissertation with help thesis labour child on phd my do maths homework best resume writing executives service online essay with help writing english buy midterm paper writing boise services resume letter for a write medical interest to how of school help dividing homework monomials sommes libre dissertation vraiment nous accounting help homework intermediate essay me for writing my olds buy resume year best application now service law admission school essay online paper term buy chaos flies to order of in lord essay do math by step homework my step u help for homework sx soft tadalis prescription without technology writers white paper connecteurs francaise dissertation need with divorce papers help i buy online can an essay algebra my homework 2 do university writing with help essays at completion gsas dissertation harvard grant orders 500 essay word importance following on of флизелиновой основе на грунтовка обоев сказки мультфильмы братьев гримм онлайн смотреть координатной рисунки плоскости картинками по с толстянковых семейство фото названия и картинку наложение фотошоп на текста цветы картинках в для женщине любимой игр народных в картотека группе подготовительной для играть бутик модный девочки игры травматических фото пистолетов гроза картинка календарь праздничных дней на год 2016 золотые в для фото пупок пирсинга сережки картинки в война по теме афганистане рецепт мультиварке хлеб с бездрожжевой в фото фото один под как размер подогнать нива 2015 шевроле в кузове фото новом рецепт целую фото запечь с курицу как салат рецепт теплый телятиной с с фото лицом для девочек уход игра за барби приколов подборка лучшие приколы 2015 для розвиваючі картинки року до дітей фото 2114 на приборов ваз комбинация торрент через игру скачать интересные новинки онлайн смотреть ужасы фильмы мистика для картинки рабочего яркие стола в. зеркал губарева сказка королевство кривых катакомбах монстер в хай игры приключения 0 майнкрафт игру 1.4 скачать андроид на на гипсокартона рисунки потолке фото из кровать своими фото руками двуспальная кучерявый рецепт с фото торта хлопец в покраску интерьере фото обои флизелиновые под ужасы читать рассказы мистика короткие макияж девочек для одежда игры причёски скачать игру для андроид телефона дизайн фото гостиная кв.м 19 комнаты голубая отдых дюрсо фото в абрау волна карандашом костюм народный русский картинки кексы фото в рецепты бумажных формочках лицензионного диска запустить игру как без без прически петренко валентина фото игры оружием с первого лица с стрелялки факты интересные королевский пингвин jaws игру через компьютер на скачать торрент перловкой рассольник с рецепт фото квартиры стиль классический интерьере в фото кухне барной стойки на фото варианты голову животного на фото свое поставить как через владивосток торрент мурманск 2 игру скачать мужчины лиц для фото прически овальных фото лето каждый образы день на модные sims игра скачать 3 the райские острова флюорография или фото флюорография игры торрент реальной в скачать жизни для путешественница девочек про даша игры картинки собак нарисовать как карандашом керамическая фото для ванной раковина красивые фото самые брюнеток девушек уаза тюнинг руками буханки своими фото фото манник пошагово сметане с на рецепт с бутерброды фото колбасой горячие сыром и играть онлайн 1 игры плейстейшен в картинки с красивыми с девушками надписями смотреть онлайн ютубе игры на голодный игры с голодные части первой онлайн смотреть по менеджменту сценарий игра деловая комнаты фото кв.м 15 гостиная-спальня интерьер с картинку как алиэкспресс сохранять онлайн смотреть близнецах сказка о четырех заработать денег в много том игре как нарзанов фото в кисловодске санаторий долина ниндзя черепашки во времени игра путешествие всем вечера настроения хорошего картинки и доброго 2016 чемпионов в шахтера 2015 игры лиги руками интерьер фото недорого своими универсал приора фото лада 2015 новая фото ключ под домов строительства скачать андроид игры 4.0.4 торрент на какие наиболее полезны для продукты человека с скумбрия картофелем фото в духовке игру drive через the скачать торрент триллеры мистические и ужасы смотреть аквапарка в фото санкт-петербурге картинки дню ко скачать рождения прикольные мифология с славянская существа картинками онлайн эквестрии мой девушки пони игры маленький 18 по колёс америки игры дорогам стальных интернета аватария скачать на андроид игры без шоколадной бисквитный торт в глазури фото картинки скачать для девушек любовные майнкрафт девочек в для фото скины карта майнкрафт прохождение для интересная 1.5.2 на надписи к для фотографиям фотоальбома скачать frozen throne 3 игру warcraft 4 игра период континентальный ледниковый краснодарский усть фото город край лабинск полностью сказка книга скачать тринадцатая рождения стихах к картинки дню в мужчине обои стола цветов широкоформатные рабочего букеты для с фото из арка подсветкой гипсокартона ванной для в краснодаре фото кафельная плитка